|
|
| |
Book ReviewsThe Tenant of Wildfell Hall |
|
|
Book: The Tenant of Wildfell Hall
Written by: Anne Bronte Jenny Agutter Alex Jennings |
Publisher: Chivers Audio Books
Average Customer Rating: 5.0 / 5
|
|
Poor Huntington
Rating:
3 / 5
I raced through this thing in 3 days - any moment that wasn't spent reading it was spent thinking about it. But at the end, I was disappointed. I guess the romantic in me was rooting for Huntington. I know he was a cruel (...), but I couldn't help liking him despite it all. I think he did truly love Helen - there was certainly no other person in the book who had a stronger influence on him, for good or for evil. I never really felt anything for Gilbert, on the other hand. He was too good or something. I wish Bronte had killed him off instead of Huntington. Even Helen would get rather obnoxious at times with her incessant moralizing. Also, the end was so lame and contrived. Anne manipulated the plot so that every "good" person lived happily ever after and every "bad" person lived a life of misery (or died). An overly simplistic view of things. But up until the last 50 pages or so, it was pretty good stuff. I've read Jane Eyre, Villette, and Wuthering Heights, and while I would say all of those are superior to The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, the Tenant is still worth reading.
An ignored masterpiece
Rating:
5 / 5
I had to read this book for school and was not very happy, however, once I began this book, I could not put it down. Bronte mixes social commentary into a novel about a woman, Helen Huntington, who is struggling to do what is right while obeying the traditions and laws of her society. We witness the struggle of this woman as she endures and abusive, alcoholic husband who engages in extramarital affairs while she tries to raise her son proper with temperance. She struggles with a new life, and the life she left behind in this often ignored novel. Anne is a literary genius whose works are only now beginning to be viewed as works of a gifted writer, and the Tenant is a great example of her supreme talent.
An Exceptionally Powerful & Disturbing Novel!
Rating:
5 / 5
Young Helen Lawrence had just come out into society, and unfortunately two of her beaus, older men who, although settled, of good character and wealthy, didn't meet her romantic standards. I can't say that I blame the talented, attractive young woman. I was not particularly turned-on by either of the men, myself. Middle-aged, stodgy and tiresome, they were not the answer to an eighteen year-old's dreams - even a practical eighteen year-old. A third suitor, Arthur Huntington, handsome, charismatic, and known by some to be "destitute of principle and prone to vice," was obviously smitten by Helen, and she was drawn to him also. Her aunt emphasized that the young woman should, above all, look for character in a potential mate. She advised her niece to seek a man of principle, good sense, respectability and moderate wealth. She warned Helen away from Huntington, calling him a reprobate. Helen agreed that she should marry such a one whose character her aunt would approve of, but also argued that love should play a part in her selection. Meanwhile, Huntington, on his best behavior, continued to woo Helen until she finally accepted his proposal, on the condition of her relatives' approval. Helen knew that Arthur was somewhat deficient in sense, scruples and conduct. However, she also truly believed that with her own strong religious convictions and love, she could and would change him for the good. In spite of numerous examples of her beloved's past lechery and excesses, Helen insisted on the match. And so they married.
Within a few months Helen became much more familiar with her husband's character. He had no hobbies nor interests, as she did. She is a gifted painter, loves to read, enjoys the outdoors, and is not easily bored. Arthur demanded all Helen's time and attention, to entertain and pamper him. When he could no longer bear the country solitude, he left for London, to reacquaint himself with his old haunts and bachelor friends. He insisted his wife remain behind, at their estate, Grassdale Manor. Huntington's behavior worsened with time, even after Helen bore him a beautiful son. He brought his debauched friends into his home for months on end, hosting wild drinking orgies and participating in a variety of low behavior extremely insulting to his wife, indeed, even encouraging his friends to mock his spouse. Helen eventually discovered that one of the houseguests, the wife of a friend, was Arthur's longtime mistress. Thus a double adultery was being conducted at Grassdale Manor, while she and her son were in residence, along with excesses of every kind.
It was at this point that Helen, contrary to the customs of her times, locked her bedroom door against her husband. This seems like logical behavior in the 21st century. And many might ask why she did not leave Huntington long before. In the Victorian Age, the law and society defined a married woman as a husband's property. Women were totally dependant upon their mates, and husbands could actually have their wives locked away in asylums at their whim and convenience. There is a scene in the novel where Arthur has all Helen's paints and canvasses destroyed, and takes possession of her jewelry and money, so she cannot leave him. When the profligate begins to manipulate his young son, encouraging the child to drink and curse his mother, Helen does run away with her child.
As the novel opens, we find her living in a few rooms at the remote Wildfell Hall, under the assumed identity of Helen Graham, a widow. Here she earns her living by painting. The neighbors are curious and seek her out, one in particular, Gilbert Markham. However when Helen is not forthcoming about her past, she becomes the object of ugly gossip and jealousy. Much of this compelling story is narrated through a series of letters Markham writes to a friend, and through Helen's own diary entries.
The novel is divided into three sections: Helen's life at Wildfell Hall and her friendship with Gilbert Markham; Helen's diary describing the Huntington marriage; and the events following Markham's reading the diary. Anne Bronte's novel is powerful, haunting and quite disturbing. Miss Bronte, and her brother Branwell, served as governess and tutor to the children of wealthy aristocrats. Some of the behavior described here is apparently taken from events which Anne witnessed, and which marked Branwell severely. Ms. Bronte openly stated that in "The Tenant of Wildfell Hall" she, "wished to tell the truth, for truth always conveys its own moral to those who are able to receive it." This well written, extraordinary tale can most definitely hold its own against the works of Anne's more famous sisters, Emily and Charlotte Bronte, and those of other noted authors of the period.
JANA
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|